Ah, the age-old debate: how should your steak be cooked?

Ask 10 people, and you'll likely receive 10 very different answers. Each steak temperature, from rare to well-done, has its band of devoted followers, each individual believing their preference is the best. But which one can truly be crowned the best?

Let's dive into the traits of each temperature.

Rare (125°F):

The devotees of rare steaks often praise the tenderness and natural flavors that this level of preparation provides. When properly prepared, a rare steak boasts a deep red center that's soft to the touch. The outer layers are seared, offering a slight crispiness that contrasts with the inner softness. Advocates argue that this method best preserves the steak's moisture and showcases its fundamental taste.

Medium Rare (135°F):

Arguably the most popular choice among steak enthusiasts, medium rare offers a perfect balance between tenderness and flavor. The center remains pink and juicy, with the outer sections featuring a deeper sear than its rare counterpart. Many chefs worldwide endorse medium rare as the optimal temperature, stating that it best represents the meat's natural flavors while ensuring a tender texture.

Medium (145°F):

Venturing into the middle ground, medium steaks present a light pink center surrounded by well-seared edges. This preparation is favored by those who are wary of too much rawness but still want a hint of juiciness. While some believe medium steaks lose a bit of their inherent beefy flavor, others appreciate the firmer texture and even cooking.

Medium Well (150°F):

This is for those who prefer their steak with a slight hint of pink at its center. Medium well ensures that most of the steak is cooked, providing a firmer texture throughout. While some critics argue that medium well steaks can be a tad dry, its proponents enjoy the consistency and believe that with the right cut and proper cooking technique, it can still be juicy and tender.

Well Done (160°F):

Often a controversial choice among steak lovers, a well-done steak is cooked completely through. While it might not have the juiciness associated with rarer temperatures, fans of well-done steaks appreciate the uniform texture and absence of any rawness. The key to a good well-done steak lies in cooking it slowly at lower temperatures in order to retain more moisture and flavor.

The best steak temperature ultimately boils down to personal preference. Whether you're a die-hard rare steak lover or a devotee of the well-done variety, it's essential to remember that the quality of the beef, the cut, and the cooking technique play a significant role in the end result. When ordering your next steak, consider experimenting with a different temperature, you just might just discover a new favorite. But regardless of where you land in the debate, there's one thing we can all agree on: There's nothing quite like a perfectly cooked steak.

So, I ask you this, do you prefer bloody or burnt?

The Art of Steak: From Bloody to Burnt

Join for free* to continue reading.